Business case casts doubt on rail extension


PRIME Minister Scott Morrison at Leawarra Station in 2018, reaffirming the federal government’s $225 million commitment to extending the Frankston line to Baxter. It has now been revealed that the cost of the project could be over a billion dollars more than that. Picture: Gary Sissons

A BUSINESS case assessing the proposed electrification of the Frankston line to Baxter has suggested that a different option be taken instead.

The business case was publicly released last week, more than one year after it was handed to the federal government.

One of five options assessed in the study only provides improvements to bus services. Two options see no electrification of the railway and add passing loops to the Stony Point line, while the other two see the track duplicated and electrified to Langwarrin and Baxter.

The study identifies the “Stony Point Uplift” as the “indicative preferred option”, rather than the electrification and duplication to Baxter.

The Stony Point uplift would see passing loops added along the Stony Point line at Tyabb and Bittern – to allow trains travelling in opposite directions to pass each other. The track would not be electrified and the project would not include level crossing removals.

The estimated cost of electrifying the Frankston line to Baxter is put at $1.3-$1.5 billion, while just going to to Langwarrin is estimated at $900m-$1.1 billion.

The Baxter electrification project would see new stations built at Frankston East, Langwarrin, and Baxter. Additional costs come from removing five level crossing, a rail bridge over Peninsula Link, train stabling at Baxter, and residential property acquisition.

Mornington Peninsula Shire councillors have warned this will impinge on the green wedge.

The federal government has committed $225 million to the electrification project while the state government has not made any commitment. This would leave the proposed project with a funding shortfall.

Frankston MP Paul Edbrooke was contacted by The News but did not respond before deadline.

The federal government’s contribution could cover the estimated $190m-$210m cost of the Stony Point uplift, the “indicative preferred option”.

The business study stated that “none of the investment options have demonstrated a strong economic case for priority investment”, but identified the Stony Point uplift as the preferred option as it “requires significantly less capital investment and has less impacts than the electrification options”.

The business case says it is a problem that “limited public transport options and poor connections between the Peninsula, Frankston and the city results in increased car dependency”

“Less than three per cent of residents use public transport in the Mornington Peninsula, and less than six per cent in Frankston, which is exceedingly low when benchmarked against municipalities with similar characteristics. The low proportion of commuters using public transport is indicative of several issues in the area, including accessibility, reliability and poor travel times. For residents in Frankston and the peninsula, less than 10 per cent of all jobs are accessible by public transport within an hour,” the business case stated.

Ginevra Hosking, CEO of lobby group Committee for Greater Frankston called the finding of the business case “Orwellian”.

“The Victorian government was given $1.5 million of public money to create this report, which purports to be a rapid cost-benefit study, but it clearly states that actually quantifying the project benefits was out of scope. The Frankston and wider community were expecting their state government to extend the train line to at least Langwarrin with a minimum 15-minute metro service and a dedicated commuter park and ride for at least 1000 cars,” she said.

“It’s time for the state government to start properly planning to construct this vital public transport project.”

Federal Flinders MP Greg Hunt, whose electorate encompasses Baxter, said “when it comes to extending Metro train service beyond Frankston, the Committee for Greater Frankston agree, the Committee for the Mornington Peninsula agree, the Mornington Peninsula Shire agree, Frankston City Council agree, the Victorian Opposition agree and the federal Liberal and Labor parties agree of the merits of this expansion.”

Dunkley MP Peta Murphy said “it took more than a year of relentless advocacy from me, including a meeting with the Deputy Prime Minister, to push the federal government to finally release the business case”.

“The Morrison government promised our community they were building the metro rail to Baxter. Yet nothing has happened. My unwavering commitment is to better public transport, including improved train services, for our community. As our local federal member, I will keep up the pressure for the Morrison government to deliver on its promises.”

The business case said about 7.4 hectares of land acquisition would be required at Baxter if the line was electrified to. Property acquisitions may also have to occur for level crossing removals at Moorooduc Highway, Hillcrest Road and Golf Links Road.

First published in the Southern Peninsula News – 17 November 2020


Comments are closed.