Devastating impact on permanent local businesses
I read your recent article regarding the clash between the Boneo Lions Club Market and the Italian Festa (“Rosebud Sunday market cancelled due to shire double booking”, The News, 2/11/26).
While it is vital that the Lions Club’s loss was highlighted, your article completely missed a major part of this local disaster: the devastating economic blow dealt to the permanent, year-round brick-and-mortar storefronts located directly across the road.
I have owned and operated Spitfire Restaurant and Grill on Point Nepean Road for over 12 years.
Because the shire approved a massive festival footprint on our busiest trading long weekend of the year without any consultation or prior notice, all public parking was entirely consumed.
With the local market cancelled and absolutely no parking available, our regular patrons had nowhere to go. This directly resulted in the worst Melbourne Cup trading weekend my business has experienced in over a decade.
To prepare for the traditionally busy holiday crowd, I heavily invested in extra rostered staff and fully stocked our kitchen. Instead, we spent the weekend managing underutilised staff and taking phone calls from frustrated customers cancelling their table reservations because they had circled the block for an hour and found nowhere to park.
We watched booked guests drive away and lost thousands of dollars in expected revenue while our wage costs skyrocketed.
The shire CEO apologized to the Lions Club, but permanent, rate-paying businesses that anchor the Rosebud economy year-round have been completely ignored.
Doris Khan, Spitfire Restaurant and Grill – Rosebud
Speed humps
As a local Mornington resident I was notified earlier in the year that the council had decided to lower the speed limit in my area to 40kph, which seemed a good idea. This happened in May and was followed by an energetic flurry of speed hump installations in Wood st, Moomba St, Seaview Ave, Bayview Rd and Oakland St. The numerous pot holes in these roads remained untouched despite some only being metres from the newly installed speed humps. Did we need the speed humps or would 40kph have been enough?
To cap things off in recent weeks the council has decided that we need to compliment shambles they’ve created at the Wilsons Road shopping area with the new traffic islands, by adding speed humps to Wilsons Road. This road is one of the main thorough fares to the beach from Nepean Highway and has a 60kph speed limit.
Surely if the council was concerned about the speed a simple and very cost effective solution would have been to just lower the speed limit to 50kph or even 40kph and see what effect that had on the traffic flow rather rip up a perfectly good road and install speed humps.
Imagine how many pot holes could have been fixed across the peninsula with the bitumen they’ve used and the money spent.
Kim Littlejohn, Mornington
Briars boardwalk
Congratulations to Mornington Peninsula Shire for the opening of the expanded wildlife sanctuary. The Briars is a very valuable asset to Mornington and Mount Martha and should be treated as such.
Therefore it is disappointing that the boardwalk is still closed as it has been for the last four years.
Even after public consultation where option 1 was voted as the best option – to upgrade the boardwalk in its current location, there has not been any progress to date.
Maybe the shire should hand over the responsibility to BERG as they are doing a fantastic job managing the boardwalk from Nepean Highway to the Esplanade.
Rotary could also be contacted for their assistance.
The Balcombe Creek Estuary is a fantastic location for families and nature lovers seeking an accessible escape for the rush of city life. It is also disappointing that the shop has closed and the restaurant also remains closed. When will the shire start looking after this valuable resource? Why do they continue to ignore it when it is such an asset to our community?
John Bridge, Mount Martha
Stealth hike
Peninsula seniors should check their myki statements closely, because a quiet fare hike has been slipped in under the cover of the state government’s “half-price” public transport rollout.
When fares were halved on 1 June, my local trips on Route 788 between Rye and Capel Sound cost 75 cents on a Seniors myki under the Regional Town Bus rate. Yet following the July bus network update, the exact same trip—tapping on and off at the exact same stops—jumped to $1.10.
Why? Transport Victoria quietly reprogrammed Route 788’s readers and shifted our local southern stops out of the regional town bus tier and into the metropolitan Zone 4 tariff.
That is a 46 per cent price rise for a short hop between neighbouring towns, disguised as a discount. Worse still, when the temporary half-price promotion ends in January, local seniors will suddenly be slugged $2.20 instead of $1.50 just to get to the shops or the doctor.
The Southern Peninsula has the highest proportion of retirees in Victoria, yet we already endure some of the poorest public transport access in Greater Melbourne. Charging local pensioners metropolitan prices for a regional bus service without a word of consultation is completely unacceptable.
Jutta Chatto, Mount Martha
Remember horses?
Grant Snowden is concerned that electric vehicles represent only 2 per cent of Australia’s vehicle fleet (“Electric dreams”, Letters, 10/11/26). Actually it’s closer to 3 per cent but let’s not quibble. Perhaps he should remember how slowly the automobile displaced the horse and cart.
When cars first appeared in Melbourne around 1900, they were expensive playthings for the wealthy. In 1920, Australia had just one motor vehicle for every 55 people. By 1929, that had increased to one for every 11. Nobody suggested the automobile was a failure because horses still dominated transport.
Mass production, falling prices, better technology and improved infrastructure eventually transformed the market.
The EV transition is following a similar pattern, but arguably much faster. In 2025, more than 156,000 battery electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles were sold in Australia, a 38 per cent increase on 2024. They accounted for 13.1 per cent of new car sales, compared with 9.6 per cent the previous year.
Of course, replacing an established fleet of 22 million vehicles takes time. But judging a technological transition by the proportion of vehicles already on the road is rather like judging the automobile in 1920 by counting the horses.
We should be celebrating this stunning new technology which is cheaper to run, has zero tailpipe emissions, and no poo on the road.
Sue Rechter, Talbot
Pier a waste
I can understand that approaching an election politicians like to get out for photo opportunities to announce spending commitments (“Marsh commits Liberals to rebuild of Flinders Pier”, The News, 3/11).
In these times of tight funding for schools, hospitals and roads and, particularly with the Liberals haranguing Labor over excess spending, Anthony Marsh has decided that building an unnecessary pier is a hill worth dying on.
Even Labor realised the expense could not be justified. Flinders’ wooden pier was demolished and a modern concrete structure built in 2011, nothing exists of the original pier so there is nothing to reconstruct or rebuild upon, it would be a complete new build so heritage considerations are largely irrelevant.
The proposed wooden pier would sit beside the existing pier and, bluntly, serves no useful purpose not provided by the existing modern pier (pictured to the right of Anthony’s right shoulder).
Seriously Anthony, what is the point of expending taxpayers money on what is little more than a vanity project when there are so many other pressing needs.
Ross Hudson, Mt Martha
Say no to gas
Two multinational companies, VOPAK and VIVA, each have proposals for LNG import terminals being considered by state government in Port Phillip Bay at Geelong and near Avalon.
Each proposal would involve massive construction, dredging, discharge of 480m litres of heavily chlorinated sea water per day back into the bay, and numerous other ongoing environmental and amenity impacts on Port Phillip Bay and surrounds.
In 2021 AGL proposed a similar terminal in Westernport Bay. A concerted community campaign resulted in AGL’s project being rejected by the federal government on a host of environmental reasons including impact on Westernport’s internationally listed Ramsar status.
These same conditions also apply to Port Phillip Bay’s Western shoreline’s Ramsar listed areas where both proposed LNG Import terminals would be located.
Though there was never any justification for importing gas from overseas into Victoria, particularly when the Victorian government has since banned the use of gas in new houses, it is now appropriate to abandon the proposed LNG Import terminals in Port Phillip Bay.
Even harder to explain is why we need to import gas at all when Australia is one of the world’s largest exporters of LNG, sending around 80% of our gas production overseas, much of it royalty free.
What’s more, after years dragging the chain, the federal government is at last legislating a 25% reservation of natural gas produced in Australia for use on our east coast.
Now, with the east coast gas reservation secured for use within Australia, if necessary the gas can enter Victoria by existing pipelines across the nation, with far less environmental damage and costs than what multinational energy companies are proposing to impose.
PPCC urges all candidates standing for the forthcoming state election to reject these unacceptable, outmoded and costly gas import proposals on social, environmental and economic grounds.
Len Warfe, President – Port Phillip Conservation Council inc.
Hidden agendas
A letter arrived in our letterbox from the Liberal Party of Australia (Victorian Division).
“Real Change has a Plan” was the title.
No real information in the letter so I clicked on ‘The Plan’ website.
The Plan had 27 photos of Liberal Leader Jess Wilson over 44 pages.
The word ‘crime’ was mentioned 38 times.
‘Jobs’ only appeared nine times and no mention of ‘rent’ or ‘pension’ or ‘homeless’.
There were a few other important words missing from the Plan.
The word ‘nuclear’ was missing – perhaps replaced by ‘technology agnostic’.
No mention of ‘coal’ or ‘hydrogen’ but ‘gas’ appeared 10 times.
No mention of AI or data centres.
No mention of ‘climate’ or ‘emissions’ or ‘carbon’.
I wondered what words would appear after the election is over.
Voters need to be fully informed about each candidate and the issues they are not talking about.
We need more than ‘bread and circuses’ from our politicians – e.g. who they represent and what their hidden agendas are.
Dale Stohr, Crib Point
Be careful with your vote
People are frustrated, angry, disillusioned with politicians and parties, and are voting for something “different” only to discover that getting rid of the old regime is much easier than building a better one.
UK Brexit: Businesses have faced new trading barriers and administrative costs. Immigration did not disappear, its composition changed. Public opinion has shifted, with polling showing considerable dissatisfaction. People voted to take back control, they did not get the control and the economic benefits they were promised! UK is now attempting to negotiate trade deals with EU to “fix the problem”.
USA Trumpism: Voters frustrated with the political establishments turned to Trumpism promising to shake up the system. Anti-establishment messaging appealed to people who felt ignored by traditional politicians. Voting against someone is not the same as voting for a workable alternative. When people vote out of anger, do they even consider what happens the day after the election? The United States 2026 midterms have demonstrated how strongly frustration can influence voting and the end result of the “draining the swamp”. Reuters described the result as a “sharp rebuke of Trumpism”.
Populism versus practical government: Anger is an effective campaigning tool, governing requires difficult decisions. Campaign slogans rarely include the consequences. Are we voting for a better future, or simply expressing our frustration with the present? Are we electing people with the ability to govern, or people who are simply good at telling us what we want to hear? A protest vote is easy, living with the consequences is considerably harder. Anger might get you into the polling booth; it won’t necessarily get you a better government. Elections are not a place to register a temporary tantrum; they determine the direction of a country for years.
Both the Brexit and Trumpism voters expressed, populism to their demise! Fed up? Had enough? Vote Independent!
Joe Lenzo, Safety Beach
Liberal savings plan
In addition to the many shortcomings in the costings in the Liberal Coalition state election promises (refer Jess Wilson’s Dodgy Costings report issued by the Labor Party) there are two significant oversights for those of us in the Nepean Electorate.
There is no mention of the $340m required to rebuild the Rosebud Hospital – in their first term (Anthony Marsh email) and no mention of the $5b (not all for Mornington Peninsula roads) to repair our roads.
In correspondence with me Anthony Marsh advised that they would acquire all the funds they require by “savings”.
In 30 years working for a federal government department, I never experienced “real savings” of that order.
Usually what passes for “savings” are deferments, cancellations and reductions in essential services.
Deferments and cancellations always result in considerably increased costings when those programs are resurrected at a later time.
Any savings the Liberal Coalition make will be a the expense of those who cannot afford them.
Ken Norris, McCrae
Don’t axe short stay levy
The short-stay levy is a good thing for the people of the Mornington Peninsula. It means visitors pay and doesn’t add another tax burden to local residents here on the peninsula.
But there is a problem. Nepean contributes a significant amount to this revenue.
We’re home to one of the largest concentrations of Airbnb and short-stay accommodation in Victoria. Yet our community doesn’t receive a fair share of the money raised by this levy.
The Liberals want to axe the levy altogether.
I reckon there’s a better approach. Keep the levy, but fight for Nepean to receive a fair and proportionate share of the revenue. And that’s exactly what I’ll fight for.
There is no issue with Airbnb or anyone offering short-stay accommodation. Tourism is important to our local economy.
But the community generating this income should also benefit from it.
The peninsula is facing a growing homelessness and housing affordability crisis. People are sleeping in cars, families are struggling to find secure accommodation. Public housing properties sit empty because essential maintenance has been neglected.
A fairer share of the levy could help fund repairs to bring vacant public housing back into use. It could support local homelessness services and provide practical assistance to people doing it tough. It could also help address the shortage of affordable housing in our community.
This isn’t about taking money away from tourism. It is about making sure the community that generates this revenue sees a meaningful return.
Nepean deserves its fair share, and I’ll fight to make sure we get it.
Kim Robbins, Independent Candidate for Nepean
Upper house voting
With early polling for the Victorian State election to commence on 18 November, we would encourage voters to keep in mind the importance of carefully allocating their vote in the Upper House.
The recent changes to the voting arrangements in the Upper House have been poorly communicated to the electorate with the VEC mail out comically short of explanation.
With more than 90% of people voting “above the line”, it is essential that people understand that a valid vote now requires numbering five of the group boxes, not one box as in past elections. Voting below the line also requires selecting 5 candidates individually.
The second important point to know is that only parties get the benefit of a being able to put their party name alongside their Group box. Independent candidates, even when they come from the same community group are not permitted any reference to that group. How is that fair?
The Mornington Peninsula electorates of Nepean, Hastings and Mornington are part of the upper house region of Eastern Victoria, which stretches from Portsea to Mallacoota and in total includes 11 lower house districts.
For those who want to vote in support of community engagement, climate action, retention of treaty and action on homelessness there is a community independent group ticket on the ballot for Eastern Victoria with candidates Antoinette Pitt and Kate Coxall.
You can find them on the ballot paper under the letter “J” for Joy.
Luke O’Brien, Independents for Mornington Peninsula
Trump’s imitators
Thanks to The News for exposing One Nation’s alignment with the Trump Administration (“Orange is the new whack – Trump off One Nation’s Christmas list?”, The News, 10/11/26), and providing the link to its now disappeared web page: tinyurl.com/trumpstyleleadership.
It makes revealing reading, with policies closely mirroring Trump’s.
Under “Energy and Environment”, it states: “Trump declared a ‘national energy emergency,’ prioritising oil and gas production, including in Alaska, and paused offshore wind projects. He also withdrew from the Paris Climate Agreement.” The One Nation position is virtually identical.
This political courtship is hardly surprising. In October 2025, mining billionaire Gina Rinehart flew One Nation leader Pauline Hanson to Florida on her private jet. They stayed at Rinehart’s Palm Beach mansion and attended Trump’s Halloween party at Mar-a-Lago. Does Rinehart see Hanson as a political mouthpiece?
With Trump’s self-interest and poor judgement increasingly under scrutiny in the US, Hanson is discovering that political imitation comes with reputational costs. Clearly she wants the Trump playbook without the Trump baggage.
Christine Cook, Essendon
Oh, Jess
Jess Wilson has finally come out declaring she put One Nation before Labor, not surprised.
One Nation does embrace Trumpism and Jess Wilson’s father is a MAGA supporter and Jess has come out saying that there is nothing wrong to having an American style health system, if you’re rich you be fine but not for the rest of us.
Jess also gets her advice from Jeff Kennett, the same Jeff Kennett that when he was Premier privatised road maintenance and that was including fixing the potholes on our roads, closed down schools, privatising our electricity and public transport and cut funding to our hospitals.
Seeing Jess has promised everything under the sun, the only way she’ll pay for her promises is do what Jeff Kennett did and cut funding everywhere and on everything.
I also don’t know why people keep falling for the Liberal promise every state and federal election about funding Rosebud Hospital, the Liberals have never kept that deal. Forty years and still waiting.
If you vote Liberals in, then you’re voting for Trumpism, budget cuts, the dangerous American style health system, One Nation and seeing the rail loop and other infrastructure that is halfway through being built, stopped & rotting away.
Jess will use billions of taxpayers’ money to cancel those contracts and see the rail loop collect dust and fall apart because of no budget to keep these projects maintained for the future.
Kerrie McCoy, Dromana
Summer coming?
First peek at the change of season.
Squadrons of Ibis flying from Westernport to Bellarine to partake of the wetlands delicacies.
Youngsters abandoning their screens to bother the local fisheries with their free fishing rods.
And the first sighting of a rectal floss bikini at the local IGA.
David Martin, Mt Martha
Proud to be Australian
The whole world is doing it tough economically due to the global economic downturn and Australia is not immune. France and Germany are dealing with riots and youth demonstrations because of their very fragile economies. Spain had a massive strike and riots regarding housing evictions and affordability. The cost to young people for housing there is 98.7 per cent of their average monthly wage.
The USA say 44 per cent of people can’t afford medical care, housing, food or transport. There’s a grim picture in Britain and all other countries too. The Brits are told to keep three days worth of supplies because of the threat of AI shutting down refrigeration etc.
Hoax bomb threats across European countries is also causing havoc to blood banks, supermarkets, broadcasters, air traffic, schools – 300 schools evacuated in Italy.
Australia is also experiencing economic hardship but we have higher wages and the highest minimum wage. We also have superannuation, Medicare and the PBS which are the envy of other countries.
We follow the rest of the western world and so our labour market is cooling just as theirs have. Our house prices are too high but, thankfully, they’re coming down.
We’re not worse off than other western countries despite what some politicians say and want us to believe.
I’m proud to be Australian and grateful that my British ancestors immigrated here.
Nerida Miller, Mount Martha
A musical feast
A couple of weeks ago at the Peninsula Community Theatre, Wilson Rd, the Mornington Peninsula Chamber Orchestra presented its third concert for 2026. The acoustics in this building are exceptional with an exciting sound full of depth and the clarity to hear every instrument. The program of Holst, Kleinig, Rodrigo and Beethoven was alive as we visited, revisited this music as only live performance can. MPCO is a local orchestra of musicians of the highest standard offering us the opportunity to be thrilled by music of the highest quality.
Locally we can enjoy the best of the best. Each year we have the MSO at Frankston, Beleura House celebrates ANAM with numerous concerts and much more, and this coming Sunday at 2.30, the Peninsula Music Society who have been bringing top, mainly Australian ensembles to Mornington for more than 60 years will present ‘Ensemble Liaison’ at Wilson Rd. There is so much more too of local ensembles and choirs like the Vox Peninsula whose seasonal concerts are in the next few weeks.
Could opportunities be better anywhere for local audiences to be enriched and for musicians of all ages to learn and perform? This is Mornington Peninsula.
Max Garrard, Mornington
Kind act
Many thanks to a bloke who recently dropped my phone at the physio in Balnarring (appointment card in phone) after finding it on the road at Main Ridge. So much appreciated – may much good karma come your way.
Stephen Leng, Balnarring
Barley Charley @ 90+
Penultimate plus? November 2026. Assuming I’m flying high, the question is what’s happening on the ground below?
I wrote a play “The Lucky Last” liked it, years ago. Runner up in some competition, shoot the judges? The rabbit lasts for 2 years, the turtle almost forever?
Re-interpreted, as in “nothing matters” (almost) coming into the 90’s, the ageing process.
And politics, politicians, aims, beliefs, concerns? Double talk; money money money, honey!
Wrong of course. Yes, money helps, but nothing in comparison to the prime importance of COMMON SENSE, a rarity seemingly? And Osmon Khawaja; selling out yes, sad.
Ok, AND family. Thankfully the toilers, the ability to restrain the non-toilers, powerwise. Ever thus (?) not necessarily, history littered with power, money, innocent deaths.
Presently, Australia dodging the bullets, sadly the likes of Paul Keating, Barrie Jones, John Clarke, Daniel Andrews, others, not to guide us.
Election Victoria; by all means vote Liberal, Greens, whoever, at least we know where they are coming from, but Pauline Hanson’s Party; prejudice and racism? Please, think again…
On family, as in mine, all different personalities, blatantly obvious. The Cabaret (of life) – the significance of watching Shetland 2017 and now 2026, same characters, changed opinions; likes, dislikes?
Ditto Inspector Morse, once a hero, now a snarly old copper. Add in favourites stage (theatre) namely Picasso at the Lapin Agile, Mates.
Gave away the acting game years ago, forced move to Lah Lah land Rye, aka Simpson Desert (first 2 years) not now, freedom?
Handy when answering annoying callers on my home phone, in German, quickly sorry, if the Meals on Wheels lady.
Almost finally (?) the question of advantage (if any?) the Rest Home or “As Is” across the Road from my RSL? Occasionally the thought of two heavies in white uniforms, knocking on my door, “Time to go old man” yet always discarded in favour of another Mighty Magpies victory, and yet, even more important, seemingly (?) the friendly smiles from so many when guiding (erratically) my scooter to Woolworths?
Whatever, time to “hit the road” John, mixing reality with dreams.
Somebody famous said “IT’S Time” – not I, as it happens It is Time, mine. Facebook; quickies, short and sweet; not so my favourite local newspaper, and appreciation, letters, enough is enough.
Sing in the shower, dance to the radio (Kurt). Fare thee well, for I must leave thee, do not let this parting grieve thee. Kisses.
Cliff Ellen, Rye



